February 20, 2011 by jhynes
My heart was racing. My eyes and brain were working feverishly together to read as fast as possible. I felt anxious, nervous, trapped - maybe to the point of claustrophobia. You don’t think “Room” by Emma Donoghue
will illicit those kinds of emotions. Then, she grabs you with a few more emotions you didn’t think you’d notice, let alone feel.
I read a review for this book in “Newsweek” a long time ago. I put it in my “I think I”d like to read this book” category, but about as quickly as I read the review, I forgot about the book. I’m glad our neighbor read the book and suggested it for book club. The book does not disappoint.
At first, I wasn’t sure I could read a story from the point of view of a 5-year-old boy. I initially found him to be quite annoying. He seemed to have a good vocabulary and could speak beyond his years, but you’re reading his thoughts, so his thought patterns were very broken and at first, hard to follow. I got used to it, and I credit the author for getting inside the mind of a 5-year-old boy and making you feel like he’s really the one explaining everything. The boy uses proper nouns for everyday things, because in his world, they are important and personal enough to capitalize. Table, Blanket, and Sink are the only friends he knows.
The story is about a boy born from captivity. Going back farther, his mom was kidnapped and kept in a 12 x 12 shed with no windows, just a skylight. Her kidnapper continuously abused her (physically, emotionally and sexually) and got her pregnant. She gave birth to Jack in that room all alone and raised him cut off from the outside world, other than a TV set and semi-regular nightly visits from their captor.
The mom in this book is faced with a harsh reality that she and her son will never leave that room. How do you raise a child in an atmosphere like that? She has to decide whether or not to tell the boy about the outside world or to explain that what he sees on TV or reads about in books is all make-believe. I don’t know how you could make that decision knowing you’ve sealed your fate in a small room or given you and your son false hope of leaving.
She also makes another calculated decision: her captor, the boy’s father, is never to look at, talk to or touch the boy. She makes Jack hide in the wardrobe when the captor comes for his visits.
I don’t want to be a spoiler. I want you to experience everything I did when I read the book. Let me just say this: The social and personal dynamics of this book are complex. I didn’t expect it but looking back, those dynamics and all the reasons why make sense. This mother and son have to survive first, but they also have to try to find a way to live and grow emotionally, spiritually, and physically. You’d be amazed at how that happens in such a small space with so few resources.
The book ends abruptly, but appropriately.
“Room” is a great book for book clubs. I can’t wait for our Friday night meeting to see where the conversation goes.